by Chris__M » 25 Oct 2010, 19:43
Heh. Elsewhere, I have experienced long and agonising debates about this.
The received wisdom is that spawning new windows or tabs automatically is impolite - if the user wishes to do so, they can, by simply right-clicking on the hyperlink. The correct action is to open the link in the current tab/window.
I know a little about this because I have experienced the same behaviour in my own boardgame forum, which uses the same phpBB system that this site uses. Version 2 of phpBB opened links in new tabs, as you (and I) prefer. phpBB3 (which this site uses) deliberately changed this behavour, without any config option; although, as Steve suggests, there are mods out there that will allow a return to the previous behaviour.
I have to say that I tend towards your point of view, and like to keep people on my site, but it is a fairly contentious point in web-mastering circles, and I have seen otherwise sensible people get quite bent out of shape over this issue.