British BBQ Society Forums

What he said. ^

Just to add that convention has been that very low scores do have to be justified to the Head Judge or Table Captain. For example, a newly-trained judge cannot just give a team a 2 for texture without a vetting process taking place.

Essays both done and submitted now so I'm off to the pub.

Good job here's to A++. As a forum we would expect nothing less doncha no!!

As long as they come back as Firsts then I'm happy.

Are their any ojections or do the judges frown upon sculpted turn in boxes ?

Regards

Eddie

They're illegal Eddie, that's stated in the rules.

Cheers Steve, at first I thought that it was a good idea ( Dr BBQ Box), It's great to have a tread like this to get confirmation, as it saves disapointment at a competition.


Regards

Eddie

At the class Ray stated that for moulding, while illegal, everyone does it at the American comps.
If that's the case, should it be made legal in IBQN, so as to better prepare UK teams for competitions in the US?

bencops wrote:At the class Ray stated that for moulding, while illegal, everyone does it at the American comps.
If that's the case, should it be made legal in IBQN, so as to better prepare UK teams for competitions in the US?

You can also adapt yourself to each competition you are in. If IBQN start bending their own rules, that’s where arguments start and inconsistent judging begins ?

Eddie

Does what Ray did count as moulding though? I know it is but it's not like he made a pork swan chasing a badger.

My personal view is that what he did makes for nice presentation but I asked in the other thread whether this would be legal.

All it takes is for one judge to stick to the rules and your box has failed. Although it isnt picked up every time i am sure it will be some of the time and personally i wouldnt want to take the risk. What we do is working well, as can be seen by the scores and results by UK teams that have competed in the states recently.